Developing evidence briefs for policy: a qualitative case study comparing the process of using a guidance-contextualization workbook in Peru and Uganda.

BACKGROUND: Translating research evidence from global guidance into policy can help strengthen health systems. A workbook was developed to support the contextualization of the WHO's 'Optimizing health worker roles to improve maternal and newborn health' (OptimizeMNH) guidance. This study evaluated the use of the workbook for the development of evidence briefs in two countries - Peru and Uganda. Findings surrounding contextual factors, steps in the process and evaluation of the workbook are presented. METHODS: A qualitative embedded case study was used. The case was the process of using the workbook to support the contextualization of global health systems guidance, with local evidence, to develop evidence briefs. Criterion sampling was used to select the countries, participants for interviews and documents included in the study. A template-organizing style and constant comparison were used for data analysis. RESULTS: A total of 19 participant-observation sessions and 8 interviews were conducted, and 50 documents were reviewed. Contextual factors, including the cadres, or groups, of health workers available in each country, the way the problem and its causes were framed, potential policy options to address the problem, and implementation considerations for these policy options, varied substantially between Peru and Uganda. However, many similarities were found in the process of using the workbook. Overall, the workbook was viewed positively and participants in both countries would use it again for other topics. CONCLUSIONS: Organizations that produce global guidance, such as WHO, need to consider institutionalizing the application of the workbook into their guidance development processes to help users at the national/subnational level create actionable and context-relevant policies. Feedback mechanisms also need to be established so that the evidence briefs and health policies arising from global guidance are tracked and the findings coming out of such guideline contextualization processes can be taken into consideration during future guidance development and research priority-setting.

El abordaje temprano y tratamiento mixto en el manejo de la esquizofrenia: Guía de práctica clínica basada en evidencia de un hospital especializado en salud mental del Ministerio de Salud del Perú / Early approach and mixed treatment in schizophrenia management: Evidence-based clinical practice guideline from a specialized mental health public hospital in the Ministry of Health of Peru

Introducción: La esquizofrenia es un trastorno psicótico caracterizado por alteración sustantiva del funcionamiento mental y efectos sobre la funcionalidad social de la persona afectada. Objetivo: Brindar recomendaciones basadas en la mejor evidencia disponible para abordaje temprano, tratamiento farmacológico y psicosocial. Métodos: Se elaboró una guía de práctica clínica basada en evidencias (GPC-BE), adaptada mediante proceso sistemático, riguroso, transparente, desarrollado por un grupo elaborador integrado por metodólogos y psiquiatras expertos en el manejo de esquizofrenia. La guía comprende cuatro preguntas clínicas y recomendaciones, se realizó búsqueda de guías que respondan al tema priorizado, se preseleccionaron y evaluaron guías mediante el instrumento "Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II" (AGREE-II), la de mejor calidad metodológica fue elegida para adaptación. La búsqueda sistemática de evidencias para cada pregunta clínica fue realizada en múltiples bases de datos: MEDLINE/Ovid, EMBASE/Ovid, EMB reviews/Ovid. La selección y análisis de evidencias se realizó mediante pares clínicos y metodológos, las recomendaciones fueron elaboradas aplicando metodología Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE). Resultados: Con participación del panel de expertos clínicos de institutos y hospitales del Perú referentes en el manejo de esquizofrenia, se elaboraron cuatro recomendaciones para la intervención temprana, tratamiento farmacológico y mixto de pacientes adultos con esquizofrenia. Conclusiones: Se recomienda el abordaje temprano del primer episodio psicótico a través de centros de salud mental comunitarios (CSMC) y hospitales especializados y tratamiento farmacológico junto a terapia psicosocial estandarizada. El presente artículo resume la guía de práctica clínica basada en evidencias elaborada por un hospital público peruano especializado en salud mental.

Introduction: Schizophrenia is a psychotic disorder characterized by substantive alteration of mental functioning and effects on the social functionality of affected individuals. Objective: Provide recommendations based on the best available evidence for early approach, pharmacological and psychosocial treatment. Methods: An Evidence-based Clinical Practice Guide (GPC-BE) was developed, adapted through a systematic, rigorous, transparent process, by a working group composed of methodologists and psychiatrists who are experts in the management of schizophrenia. The guide includes four clinical questions and recommendations, we searched for guides that respond to the prioritized topic, guides were pre-selected and evaluated using the "Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II" (AGREE-II) instrument, the one with the best methodological quality was chosen for adaptation. The systematic search for evidence for each clinical question was performed in multiple databases: MEDLINE / Ovid, EMBASE / Ovid, EMB reviews / Ovid. The selection and analysis of evidence was carried out using clinical pairs and methodologists, the recommendations were prepared using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) methodology. Results: With the participation of the panel of clinical experts from institutes and hospitals in Peru in the management of schizophrenia, four recommendations were established for the early intervention, pharmacological and mixed treatment of adult patients with schizophrenia. Conclusions: The early approach of the first psychotic episode through community mental health centers (CSMC) and specialized hospitals and pharmacological treatment together with standardized psychosocial therapy is recommended. This article summarizes the evidence-based clinical practice guideline developed by a Peruvian public hospital specializing in mental health disorders.

Políticas e intervenciones para reducir lesiones por accidentes de tránsito: de la evidencia a la práctica / Policies and interventions to reduce injuries due to traffic accidents: From evidence to practice

Este artículo presenta intervenciones para prevenir la mortalidad y lesiones por accidentes de tránsito (AT), desde la evidencia científica y perspectiva de los actores involucrados. Para ello se realizó una búsqueda sistemática, se organizó un resumen de políticas con participación de actores clave para finalmente realizar un dialogo deliberativo con representantes técnicos de las diversas instituciones relacionadas con el abordaje del problema propuesto. Describe las intervenciones relacionadas a educación, infraestructura vial, asistencia pre-hospitalaria, normatividad y fiscalización que fueron insumo para la contextualización a nuestro medio local. Los representantes técnicos multisectoriales aportaron consideraciones para su implementación, los potenciales beneficios o daños, el uso de recursos, adaptaciones necesarias, posibles barreras y facilitadores para su abordaje. Presenta el rol canalizador que desarrolló el Instituto Nacional de Salud para colaborar en la transferencia de la evidencia a la práctica. Asimismo, plantea necesidades de investigación, que requieren ser abordados en las intervenciones integrales de seguridad vial.

This article presents interventions to prevent mortality and injuries from traffic accidents (TA), from the scientific evidence and perspective of the actors involved. For this purpose, a systematic search was carried out, a policy summary was organized with the participation of key actors to finally carry out a deliberative dialogue with technical representatives of the various institutions related to the approach of the proposed problem. Describe evidence-based interventions related to education, integral infrastructure, pre-hospital assistance, regulations and control that were deliberate and contextualized to our local environment. The multi-sector technical representatives contributed considerations for its implementation, the potential benefits or damages, the use of resources, necessary adaptations, possible barriers and facilitators for its approach. It presents the channeling role that National Institute of Health developed to collaborate in the transfer of evidence to practice. It also raises research needs, which need to be addressed in comprehensive road safety interventions.

Guía de práctica clínica para el diagnóstico y tratamiento de la enfermedad diarreica aguda en niños menores de 5 años: versión extensa / Clinical practice guideline for the diagnosis and treatment of acute diarrheal disease in children under 5 years of age: long version

Este documento abarca temas de diagnóstico y tratamiento de la enfermedad diarreica aguda en niños menores de 5 años.